For renters seeking some of the most affordable housing within a short commute of downtown Pittsburgh, Carrick offers one of the city’s best values. Located approximately five miles south of downtown, this residential neighborhood provides a 10 to 20 minute commute to the city center while maintaining rental rates that are significantly below both the national average and most Pittsburgh neighborhoods. With median rents around $1,200 per month and average one-bedroom rents of approximately $900, Carrick is a practical choice for budget-conscious renters who want to be close to the city without paying premium prices.
Carrick appeals to renters who prioritize affordability, a quiet residential setting, and access to public transportation over urban nightlife and dense walkability. Known to locals as “the Hilltop,” the neighborhood is filled with green space, parks, and a strong sense of community. The median rent in Carrick is well below the national average, saving renters significantly compared to the typical U.S. rental market.
Location and Commute
Carrick’s position in the South Hills provides convenient access to Pittsburgh and the surrounding region. The neighborhood sits about five miles south of downtown, with a typical commute of 10 to 20 minutes by car or public transit.
Commute to Pittsburgh
The drive from Carrick to downtown Pittsburgh takes approximately 10 to 15 minutes via Brownsville Road or Route 51, connecting to the Liberty Tunnels less than two miles away. For those who prefer public transit, Carrick is well-served by Port Authority buses along Brownsville Road, with the Denise T Station also located in the neighborhood for light rail access. Buses run frequently on weekdays, making carless commutes convenient for residents.
Walkability
Carrick is a walkable neighborhood with a reasonable Walk Score, indicating that some errands can be accomplished on foot. Brownsville Road, the main thoroughfare, has shops, restaurants, and a grocery store within walking distance of many residences. The neighborhood also has some public transit options.
The Carrick Rental Market
Carrick’s rental market consistently ranks among the most affordable in Pittsburgh while offering a range of options across different property types. The average rent in Carrick is well below the national average.
Rental Prices
Rental rates in Carrick offer exceptional value compared to both the national average and many Pittsburgh neighborhoods. The median rent is approximately $1,200 per month, with many rentals falling between $750 and $1,500 per month.
A breakdown of average rents by bedroom count shows:
- Studio apartments average approximately $700 per month
- One-bedroom apartments average approximately $750 to $900 per month
- Two-bedroom apartments average approximately $850 to $1,200 per month
- Three-bedroom apartments average approximately $1,500 per month
Some units include utilities such as gas, water, heat, trash, and sewer in the rent.
Rental Housing Stock
The rental market in Carrick includes:
- Well-maintained apartments in established buildings
- Converted single-family homes and duplexes
- Units with hardwood floors, high ceilings, and covered porches
- Properties with off-street parking and fenced yards
- Newly renovated units with modern kitchens and bathrooms
Many units in Carrick retain character features such as hardwood floors and front porches, while newly renovated properties offer modern finishes including central air conditioning and stainless steel appliances.
Rental Inventory
With a moderate number of rentals available in the Carrick area, the market offers a range of options. The number of available rentals has increased in recent years, expanding choices for renters. Rent prices have remained relatively stable.
Community Character and Amenities
Carrick has a distinct character shaped by its residential setting, green spaces, and strong sense of community.
Residential Character
Carrick is known as a diverse, family-friendly neighborhood with a strong community spirit. The neighborhood offers a suburban feel within the city, with a quiet, residential atmosphere that appeals to families and long-term residents.
Phillips Park
The neighborhood’s largest green space, Phillips Park, offers walking paths, a disc golf course, scenic trails, overlooks, a recreation center, and a swimming pool. The park hosts community events such as outdoor movies, live jazz concerts in the summer, and fitness walks.
Brownsville Road Commercial District
Carrick’s main street is Brownsville Road, lined with shopping options and local businesses. A grocery store, a Carnegie Library branch, and the Carrick Community Pavilion—which hosts farmers markets in the summer and fall—are all located along this corridor.
Schools
For renters with children, Carrick is served by Pittsburgh Public Schools, including Concord K-5 and Carrick High School, which offers specialized programs.
Practical Considerations for Renters
Rent Affordability
Carrick’s median rent is well below the national average, making it one of the most affordable neighborhoods in the Pittsburgh region. With many rentals falling between $750 and $1,500 per month, renters at almost any budget can find options.
Car Dependency
Carrick offers a middle ground in terms of walkability. The Brownsville Road commercial district is walkable for residents living within a half-mile radius, allowing for errands on foot. However, the neighborhood lacks the extensive retail options of larger commercial districts. Most residents maintain a car for commuting and regional travel, though public transportation options make car-lite living possible.
Rental Inventory
The rental market in Carrick offers a range of options with a moderate number of rentals available at any given time. Renters should monitor listings regularly and be prepared to act when suitable properties become available.
Pet Policies
Many rental properties in Carrick are pet-friendly, though policies and fees vary. Some landlords allow pets with a pet fee and monthly pet rent. Others consider pets on a case-by-case basis. Renters with pets should confirm policies before applying.
Comparing Carrick to Other Affordable Neighborhoods
For renters considering Carrick, it helps to understand how it compares to alternative locations.
Versus Brookline
Compared to Brookline, Carrick offers similar rental rates with a slightly quieter residential character. Brookline has a more developed commercial corridor along Brookline Boulevard. Both neighborhoods provide short commutes to downtown.
Versus Beechview
Compared to Beechview, Carrick offers similar rental rates and a more suburban feel. Beechview has T light rail access and a more walkable commercial district. Carrick provides a quieter residential setting with good bus and light rail connections.
Versus Dormont
Compared to Dormont, Carrick offers lower rental rates and a more residential character. Dormont provides T light rail access and a more developed commercial district with restaurants and shops.
Making the Decision
Carrick serves renters who prioritize affordability, a quiet residential environment, and access to public transportation over urban nightlife and dense walkability. For those seeking rental rates significantly below the national average and a neighborhood with green space and a strong community feel, it represents one of the best values in Pittsburgh.
The neighborhood works well for downtown commuters seeking a short commute and affordable housing. It suits renters who appreciate a residential setting with parks and local shops. It accommodates those who prefer a suburban feel within the city limits.
For renters considering Carrick, visiting the neighborhood during weekdays and weekends provides a complete picture. Experiencing the commute via Brownsville Road or public transit, exploring Phillips Park and the Brownsville Road commercial district, and touring available apartments helps determine whether the South Hills lifestyle aligns with personal preferences. For many renters in the Pittsburgh region, Carrick offers the right combination of affordability, convenience, and community character.