For renters exploring the eastern suburbs of Pittsburgh, Monroeville and Penn Hills present two distinct options with different strengths. Both communities offer convenient access to the city, but they differ in rental costs, housing stock, commute times, and overall character. This comparison examines rent prices, lifestyle factors, and practical considerations to help you decide which suburb fits your needs.
Rental Cost Comparison
The most significant difference between these two communities is rental pricing. Monroeville commands higher rents across all unit sizes, reflecting its position as a more established commercial hub with greater amenities.
| Unit Type | Penn Hills Average Rent | Monroeville Average Rent |
|---|---|---|
| Studio | $890 | $1,030 |
| 1 Bedroom | $930 | $1,080 – $1,227 |
| 2 Bedroom | $1,130 – $1,150 | $1,310 – $1,516 |
| 3 Bedroom | $1,430 | $1,660 – $1,721 |
Monroeville’s overall median rent is higher than Penn Hills, with one-bedroom units averaging around $1,080 to $1,227 per month and two-bedroom units averaging $1,310 to $1,516. Penn Hills offers more budget-friendly options, with one-bedroom units averaging around $930 and two-bedroom units around $1,130. For renters with a tighter budget, Penn Hills provides more affordable entry points while still offering convenient city access.
Commute and Accessibility
Both suburbs offer reasonable commutes to downtown Pittsburgh, but Monroeville has an edge in transportation infrastructure.
Monroeville is a commuter’s dream, strategically located at the junction of the Pennsylvania Turnpike and Parkway East. The average one-way commute takes approximately 28 minutes, and the area is served by multiple Port Authority bus routes connecting to downtown Pittsburgh, East Busway, Oakland, and surrounding communities. The bus network makes Monroeville particularly accessible for commuters who prefer public transit.
Penn Hills is located approximately 9 miles from downtown Pittsburgh, with an average commute of about 20 minutes by car. The community is situated along the Monroeville exit of I-376, making downtown Pittsburgh, Shadyside, and Oakland accessible within about 20 minutes. Public transit options exist but are less extensive than Monroeville’s bus network.
Community Character
Monroeville
Monroeville is a larger community with approximately 28,600 residents. It functions as a significant commercial hub in the eastern suburbs, anchored by the Monroeville Mall and numerous shopping and dining options. The area offers a suburban feel with substantial amenities close at hand, making it popular for professionals and families who want convenient access to retail and entertainment without traveling into the city.
Penn Hills
Penn Hills has approximately 41,100 residents, making it a larger community overall. The area offers more of a residential, suburban feel with diverse housing options ranging from starter homes to larger properties. Penn Hills is known for its lush greenery and numerous parks, including Duff Community Park, Penn Hills Community Park, and Universal Park. The community appeals to families and those seeking a quieter residential environment with easy city access.
Parks and Recreation
Monroeville offers Boyce Park, which provides skiing, snowboarding, and a wave pool in the summer months. The Monroeville Convention Center hosts events year-round.
Penn Hills is surrounded by green spaces, including Frick Park, Boyce Park, and Schenley Park. The community offers more immediate access to natural recreation, with trails and wooded areas woven into the residential fabric.
Shopping and Dining
Monroeville has a clear advantage in shopping, anchored by the Monroeville Mall, which features a variety of stores. The area offers numerous dining options, from casual eateries to upscale Italian restaurants.
Penn Hills offers convenient shopping centers including Penn Hills Shopping Center and Lincoln Park Community Center for recreation. Dining options include local favorites like Capri Pizza, Ladles, and Frankstown Wood Fired Pizza, which specializes in wood-fired pizzas and fresh pasta.
Which Should You Choose?
Choose Monroeville if you:
- Prefer a more established commercial hub with abundant shopping and dining options
- Rely on public transit for commuting to Pittsburgh
- Are willing to pay higher rents for convenience and amenities
- Work in the eastern suburban corridor or downtown and want bus access
Choose Penn Hills if you:
- Prioritize lower rental costs and want more space for your budget
- Prefer a quieter, more residential community with access to parks and green space
- Don’t mind a slightly longer commute or prefer driving over transit
- Seek a family-friendly environment with suburban tranquility
Both communities offer convenient access to Pittsburgh while providing distinct lifestyles. Monroeville’s commercial amenities and transit options come at a higher cost, while Penn Hills offers more affordable living with a quieter residential character. Your choice depends on whether you prioritize convenience and amenities or budget and tranquility.